In Iowa this week, distillers grains were asked at an average of $166.36/ton. A few hours' drive away, 85 tons of hay cleared the Rock Valley, Iowa auction at $168/ton.

Same state, same week, nearly the same sticker. One of those numbers is up 20.9% from a year ago. The other fell 11.5% from last week.

That is the story of the winter feed bill right now. The byproduct side of the ration got expensive. The hay side didn't. Our national alfalfa average held at $161/ton, flat on the week, while the broader hay benchmark edged up just 1.0% to $177.

The ration's two halves came apart

Here's how the feed lines stack up this week.

FeedWherePriceSignal
Distillers grainsIowa, avg asked$166.36/ton+20.9% vs a year ago
CornIowa, delivered to ethanol plants$4.25/buWeek of Nov 9
HayRock Valley, IA$168/ton-11.5% on 85 tons vs 5 last week
AlfalfaNational avg$161/tonFlat week over week
Good alfalfa3 markets$194/ton-3.1%, down $6
GrassNational avg$117/ton+4.2% week over week

A caveat before anyone rewrites a ration off a table: distillers grains and hay are not the same feed. One is a protein-and-energy concentrate, the other is forage, and they don't swap pound for pound. But rations get balanced at the margin, and the margin is exactly where relative price matters. When the concentrate gets dearer and the forage holds still, the cheapest way to fill a cow shifts toward the hay barn. The Iowa Beef Center's substitution worksheet is the right tool for running that math on your own nutrient numbers.

The Rock Valley print is the one to take seriously. Last week that auction traded 5 tons. This week it moved 85 tons and the price came down to $168. That's not a thin sale wobbling the average. That's real hay finding real buyers at a lower number, in the same state where distillers grains are running hot. See the Iowa price page for the full run.

The buyer with the most to gain: the dairy

No one feels this split harder than a dairy. The all-milk price sits at $19.50/cwt, down 4.4% from a year ago. Milk cow numbers are up 2.1% to 9.65M head. More mouths, smaller checks, and a byproduct feed that costs 20.9% more than it did last year.

Against that, the forage line is the friendly one. Good alfalfa slipped $6 to $194/ton across the markets reporting it. The plain alfalfa average didn't budge. For a dairy squeezed on both the revenue and the concentrate side, quality hay that is holding or easing is the one input working in its favor this fall.

The beef side is quieter. Cattle on feed are at 11.37M head, -0.4% versus a year ago, and the beef cow herd is down 0.7%. Feedlot demand is easing, not surging, which is part of why hay isn't chasing the distillers market higher.

Flat is not the same as cheap forever

Hay holding still while substitutes climb is a window, not a permanent state. The supply backdrop leans tight:

- The 2026 U.S. hay crop is forecast at 120.5M tons, -2.0% vs 2025. - 45% of U.S. hay acreage is in drought, against 34% a year ago. - Hay exports ran 207,804 metric tons in September, +4.3% vs a year ago, with Japan, China and South Korea taking the bulk of it out of Washington, California and Oregon.

A smaller crop, more hay ground under drought, and export buyers taking more. None of that pushes prices down over a winter.

ALFALFA OUTLOOK

Our 8-week smoothed alfalfa trend reads steady, medium confidence, with a projected range of $145-$170/ton off a recent level of $160/ton. Source: USDA AMS.

So the near-term call is steady, not cheaper. And freight is helping at the edges: U.S. diesel sits at $6.13/gal, down $0.17 on the week, which makes delivered loads a touch cheaper than they were.

The playbook

Buyers: the forage side of the ration is the stable piece right now, and stable pieces are the ones worth locking. If you're balancing a winter ration and distillers grains have been carrying a big share of it, this is the week to price the hay alternative against your own numbers. Shop the volume, not the headlines: Rock Valley showed real tonnage at $168. Don't chase the top of the spread. Dakota, SD sat at $228, a $59 gap over Rock Valley, and Pipestone, MN's 23.6% jump to $185 came on just 8 tons.

And don't assume every hay line is quiet. Grass rose 4.2% to $117 while mixed grass fell 7.5% to $170. Know which one your ration actually needs.

Sellers: your pitch writes itself. Every dairy and feeder doing ration math this month is looking at a concentrate bill that's up by a fifth. Hay that held its price looks better by comparison every week that gap persists. Sell the comparison, and sell it to the buyers whose milk checks are shrinking.

The headline hay number barely moved this week. That's exactly why it matters. When everything else in the feed bill climbs, standing still is a price cut.